Product Engineering
A gauge can pass on study variation and fail on tolerance. Both criteria matter.
— %
Under 10% acceptable, 10–30% conditional, over 30% unacceptable (AIAG MSA)
Variances add, standard deviations do not, so every combination here is a root-sum-square. Percent of study variation and percent of tolerance answer different questions and frequently disagree: the first depends on how representative the specimens were, so a study run on deliberately similar samples flatters the gauge and one run on extremes flatters it further. Percent of tolerance is the criterion that matters when the gauge is used to accept or reject against a specification, and it is independent of the specimens chosen. The ndc figure uses the AIAG 1.41 constant and should be at least 5; below 2 the gauge cannot distinguish parts at all and is only counting. None of this detects bias — a systematically wrong instrument can be perfectly repeatable and perfectly reproducible. Calibrate against a traceable standard as a separate exercise.
Measurement System Analysis (Gage R&R) Calculator — free, with the formula and a worked example, at Textile School.