Jump to a calculator 671 tools
Product Engineering
Specification Tolerance Cost-of-Quality Modeler
Reject rate is exponential in sigma. A small tightening is never a small cost.
Additional Annual Reject Cost
— currency
Cost of accepting the tighter limit without improving the process
Capability & Improvement Cost
- Current Sigma Level
- — σ
- Current Reject Rate
- — ppm
- Proposed Reject Rate
- — ppm
- SD Needed to Hold Capability
- — units
- SD Reduction Required
- — %
- Process Improvement Cost
- — currency
Reject rates assume a centred, normally distributed process, which is the optimistic case on both counts. A real process drifts, and the widely used 1.5σ long-term shift would raise these ppm figures substantially; a distribution with heavier tails than normal — which most textile strength data has — raises them further, and the error is largest exactly where it matters, out at the specification limit. Treat the ppm figures as a lower bound and the cost comparison as a ratio rather than a forecast. The linear improvement cost is a planning placeholder: variation reduction gets progressively harder, so the last 10% typically costs more than the first 30%. Neither route priced here includes the cost of the customer relationship if the tighter tolerance is refused.
Using this calculator
About the Specification Tolerance Cost-of-Quality Modeler
The formula
This is the expression the tool evaluates. Every term is named underneath, with the unit it must be supplied in.
additionalRejectCost = f( currentTolerance, proposedTolerance, processSd, rejectCost, unitsPerYear, costPerSdPoint )Each input feeds the expression evaluated in the browser; the symbol table below names every term and its unit.
| Symbol | Stands for | Unit |
|---|---|---|
currentTolerance | Current Tolerance (±) | units |
proposedTolerance | Proposed Tolerance (±) | units |
processSd | Process Standard Deviation | units |
rejectCost | Cost per Reject | currency |
unitsPerYear | Annual Volume | units/yr |
costPerSdPoint | Cost per 1% SD Reduction | currency |
additionalRejectCost | Additional Annual Reject Cost | currency |
currentSigmaLevel | Current Sigma Level | σ |
currentRejectRate | Current Reject Rate | ppm |
proposedRejectRate | Proposed Reject Rate | ppm |
requiredSd | SD Needed to Hold Capability | units |
sdReductionNeeded | SD Reduction Required | % |
processImprovementCost | Process Improvement Cost | currency |
How the result is derived
Step by step, from the values you type to the figure on screen.
- The 6 inputs are read from the form on every keystroke: Current Tolerance (±), Proposed Tolerance (±), Process Standard Deviation, Cost per Reject, Annual Volume and Cost per 1% SD Reduction.
- Each value is checked against the accepted range in the input table below. A value outside its range stops the calculation rather than producing a misleading figure — the results blank out and a message appears.
- The validated values are substituted into the expression above, which resolves Additional Annual Reject Cost together with every supporting figure in one pass — no value is carried over from a previous entry.
- The supporting outputs — Current Sigma Level, Current Reject Rate, Proposed Reject Rate, SD Needed to Hold Capability, SD Reduction Required and Process Improvement Cost — come from the same pass, so they always describe the same case as the headline figure.
- Results are rounded for display only. The full-precision value is used throughout the chain, so reading a rounded intermediate figure back into the tool by hand can shift the last digit.
What each input means
Where to read each value on the floor, the unit it must be in, and the range the tool accepts.
| Input | Unit | Accepted range | Default | What it means |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Current Tolerance (±) | units | 0.001 to 1000 units | 5 | |
| Proposed Tolerance (±) | units | 0.001 to 1000 units | 3.5 | |
| Process Standard Deviation | units | 0.001 to 500 units | 1.25 | |
| Cost per Reject | currency | 0 to 100000 currency | 12 | |
| Annual Volume | units/yr | 1 to 100000000 units/yr | 240000 | |
| Cost per 1% SD Reduction | currency | 0 to 10000000 currency | 3200 | Capital and process work to cut variation |
What the tool returns
The headline figure and every supporting value it is built from.
| Output | Unit | What it tells you |
|---|---|---|
| Additional Annual Reject Cost (headline result) | currency | Cost of accepting the tighter limit without improving the process |
| Current Sigma Level | σ | |
| Current Reject Rate | ppm | |
| Proposed Reject Rate | ppm | |
| SD Needed to Hold Capability | units | |
| SD Reduction Required | % | |
| Process Improvement Cost | currency |
Worked example
Given
- Current Tolerance (±)
- 5 units
- Proposed Tolerance (±)
- 3.5 units
- Process Standard Deviation
- 1.25 units
- Cost per Reject
- 12 currency
- Annual Volume
- 240000 units/yr
- Cost per 1% SD Reduction
- 3200 currency
The tool loads with this case already solved — the Additional Annual Reject Cost shown above is its answer. Change one value and the difference from this baseline is the sensitivity of the result to that variable.
How to use it
- Work through the input groups in order — Specification Change and Economics. The defaults are a realistic case, so you can change one value at a time and watch what moves.
- There is no calculate button. Every figure recalculates as you type or drag, which is what makes this usable for a what-if sweep rather than a single answer.
- Read Additional Annual Reject Cost in the dark results panel — that is the headline figure, expressed in currency.
- Check the supporting rows underneath (Current Sigma Level, Current Reject Rate, Proposed Reject Rate, SD Needed to Hold Capability, SD Reduction Required and Process Improvement Cost) before acting on the headline — they are where an implausible input usually shows itself first.
- Reset to defaults returns every field to the reference case, which is the quickest way to check whether a surprising result came from the tool or from an input you had changed earlier.
Where this is used
- Process planning — establishing Additional Annual Reject Cost before a trial is booked, so machine time and material in Product Engineering, Specifications & Feasibility are committed against a calculated figure rather than an estimate.
- Costing and quotation — Additional Annual Reject Cost is an input to the cost sheet, and quoting from a worked number rather than a remembered one is what keeps a margin intact.
- Troubleshooting — when the floor result drifts from plan, entering the measured values (starting with Current Tolerance (±)) shows how much of the gap in Additional Annual Reject Cost each variable explains.
- Teaching and study — the accepted ranges bracket normal Product Engineering, Specifications & Feasibility practice, so moving one variable at a time shows the shape of the relationship rather than a single answer.
Assumptions and limits
- Reject rates assume a centred, normally distributed process, which is the optimistic case on both counts. A real process drifts, and the widely used 1.5σ long-term shift would raise these ppm figures substantially; a distribution with heavier tails than normal — which most textile strength data has — raises them further, and the error is largest exactly where it matters, out at the specification limit. Treat the ppm figures as a lower bound and the cost comparison as a ratio rather than a forecast. The linear improvement cost is a planning placeholder: variation reduction gets progressively harder, so the last 10% typically costs more than the first 30%. Neither route priced here includes the cost of the customer relationship if the tighter tolerance is refused.
- Every input is bounded to the range normal practice occupies (Current Tolerance (±) 0.001 to 1000 units, Proposed Tolerance (±) 0.001 to 1000 units and Process Standard Deviation 0.001 to 500 units, and so on for the rest). Those bounds are guard rails against typing errors, not a claim that the formula fails one unit outside them.
- The calculation is deterministic: the same inputs always give the same result. It carries no allowance for machine condition, operator skill, ambient conditions or lot-to-lot material variation unless an input above explicitly represents one.
- Nothing is sent anywhere. The maths runs in your browser, so the numbers you type never leave the page.
Questions people ask
What do I need to know before using the Specification Tolerance Cost-of-Quality Modeler?
Have these to hand: Current Tolerance (±), Proposed Tolerance (±), Process Standard Deviation, Cost per Reject, Annual Volume and Cost per 1% SD Reduction. With those entered, the tool returns Additional Annual Reject Cost immediately.
What exactly is Additional Annual Reject Cost?
Cost of accepting the tighter limit without improving the process. It is reported in currency. It is derived from Current Tolerance (±), Proposed Tolerance (±), Process Standard Deviation, Cost per Reject, Annual Volume and Cost per 1% SD Reduction, and is the figure the rest of the Product Engineering, Specifications & Feasibility calculation is built around.
Which units does this calculator expect?
Enter Current Tolerance (±) in units, Proposed Tolerance (±) in units, Process Standard Deviation in units, Cost per Reject in currency, Annual Volume in units/yr and Cost per 1% SD Reduction in currency. Mixing unit systems is the most common cause of a result that looks an order of magnitude wrong — convert before typing, not after reading.
What are the other figures under the main result?
They are the intermediate quantities the calculation passes through: Current Sigma Level, Current Reject Rate, Proposed Reject Rate, SD Needed to Hold Capability, SD Reduction Required and Process Improvement Cost. They are shown because a headline number nobody can trace is a number nobody trusts — checking them against your own expectation is the fastest way to confirm the inputs were read as you intended.
Can I rely on this for a production decision?
Reject rates assume a centred, normally distributed process, which is the optimistic case on both counts. A real process drifts, and the widely used 1.5σ long-term shift would raise these ppm figures substantially; a distribution with heavier tails than normal — which most textile strength data has — raises them further, and the error is largest exactly where it matters, out at the specification limit. Treat the ppm figures as a lower bound and the cost comparison as a ratio rather than a forecast. The linear improvement cost is a planning placeholder: variation reduction gets progressively harder, so the last 10% typically costs more than the first 30%. Neither route priced here includes the cost of the customer relationship if the tighter tolerance is refused. Treat the output as an engineering estimate that narrows the trial window, not as a substitute for the trial.