Home » Resources & General » Assorted » Shuttle Loom vs Shuttleless Loom: Weft Insertion, Speed and Selvedge Compared

Shuttle Loom vs Shuttleless Loom: Weft Insertion, Speed and Selvedge Compared

A shuttle loom throws a pirn-carrying shuttle across the warp; shuttleless looms send only the yarn, by projectile, rapier, air or water, faster and wider.

A row of wooden frame handlooms in a weaving shed, white cloth wound on each cloth beam and weights in cloth bags hanging below

The difference between shuttle and shuttleless looms is how the weft crosses the warp. A shuttle loom carries it in a shuttle, a heavy carrier with a pirn of yarn inside, which is struck from one side to the other and back; the weft is one unbroken thread that turns at each edge and makes a closed selvedge. A shuttleless loom leaves the yarn on a cone beside the machine and sends only a measured length across, gripped by a projectile or a rapier or blown by a jet of air or water, then cuts it, so its edges have to be tucked in, bound with leno threads or fused. Losing the shuttle is what lets shuttleless looms run faster and wider: Picanol’s first shuttle loom ran at about 140 picks a minute, against more than 800 for its current rapier and up to 1,350 for its air-jet. They also need no pirn winding and never stop to change a pirn. Shuttle looms survive where the hand process or the closed edge is part of what is being sold: handloom, khadi and selvedge denim.

Last verified: 11 October 2026. Speeds are in picks per minute (ppm), which on a single-width loom is its rpm. Weft insertion rate, in metres of weft per minute, is ppm × the width the weft crosses. Sources are linked in the text and listed at the end.

Shuttle and shuttleless looms at a glance

ShuttleProjectileRapierAir-jetWater-jet
What carries the weftA shuttle with a pirn insideA small steel gripperA rod or tape; two rapiers hand over mid-shedA main nozzle and relay nozzlesA jet of water
Weft supplyPirn in the shuttle, changed oftenCone beside the machineCone beside the machineCone beside the machineCone beside the machine
Speed, as makers state itAbout 140 ppm (Picanol’s first loom, 1936)No ppm published; up to 1,570 m/min of weftUp to 600, or more than 800, ppmUp to 1,350 ppmOver 1,000 rpm
Widths offered todayNo current maker’s figure220 to 655 cm150 to 540 cm140 to 400 cm150 to 280 cm
SelvedgeClosed by the weft itselfTucked in; leno or melted as optionsTucked in, leno or meltedLeno; tucked in as an optionLeno
Weft it takesAlmost anyAny: spun, filament or tapeThe widest range; 12 to 16 coloursSpun and filament; up to 8 coloursSynthetic filament only
Energy, in textbook comparisonsModerateLowest of the solid carriersHighHighestLowest
Where it is usedHandloom, khadi, selvedge denimVery wide and technical clothFashion, furnishing, jacquardLong runs of staple-fibre clothPolyester and nylon filament cloth

What is a shuttle loom?

A shuttle is a pointed, boat-shaped carrier with a pirn (a small bobbin) of weft inside. It stores the weft, carries it across the shed and lets it unwind through an eye in its side as it flies (UPTTI lecture notes). On a power loom a cam-driven picking stick strikes it out of a box at one side, it flies through the shed along the sley, and the box at the far side checks it to a stop; the next pick goes back the other way.

Every limit of the shuttle loom follows from that. A shuttle of about 450 g carries a pick of cotton weft weighing about 0.2 g a metre, and the noise of throwing and stopping it “can be as high as 110dB” (NPTEL course on shuttleless weaving, IIT Delhi). For a given width, the energy for each pick rises with the square of the loom speed and the picking power with its cube (Istanbul Technical University course notes), so a shuttle loom run 50% faster needs about 3.4 times the picking power. And the pirn inside the shuttle is small, so it has to be changed often, and a plain loom stops each time it runs out (UPTTI). John Kay invented the fly shuttle in 1733 (Science Museum Group), and in the 1890s James Northrop of the Draper Corporation patented the bobbin battery, which refills the shuttle without stopping the loom. Draper looms built in 1913 and 1922, still running in the weave room of the Boott Cotton Mills in Lowell, Massachusetts, run at “approximately 140-150 ppm” (US National Park Service).

What is a shuttleless loom?

A shuttleless loom keeps the weft supply outside the shed. Yarn runs from a cone beside the machine through a weft feeder that measures a length for each pick; only that length crosses the warp, and it is cut at the edge. The cone can be changed while the loom runs, and the pick is laid under controlled tension instead of unwinding from a flying pirn (UPTTI). The carrier is solid (a projectile or a rapier) or fluid (air or water). ISO 5247-1 sets the vocabulary and classification of weaving machines, and the site’s guide to types of fabric weaving looms places these four among the other loom families.

A modern rapier weaving machine with a cream warp, a stand of weft cones at the left and control panels at both ends
A rapier loom. The weft comes from the cones on the stand at the left; only the yarn end crosses the warp. Photo: Indian Textile Magazine.

Projectile (gripper) looms

A small steel gripper clamps the weft end, is fired by a twisted torsion bar, pulls the yarn across through a guide of ribbed teeth and lets go; it returns under the shed on a conveyor while others circulate, so every pick comes from the same side. The projectile weighs about a tenth of a shuttle (ITU projectile notes). Sulzer introduced it in 1953 (Sulzer); Itema, the only maker today, moved production from Zuchwil in Switzerland to Colzate in Italy in May 2026 (Itema). Its current model comes in widths from 220 to 655 cm, takes “any weft material”, spun, filament or tape, in up to six colours, and states a weft insertion rate of up to 1,570 m/min, “attained at lower machine speeds” (Itema P7300HP; brochure). Width, not speed, is the point of it. The site’s guide to the projectile loom goes through the mechanism in detail.

Rapier looms

The weft rides on the head of a rod or a flexible tape. Most rapier looms use two: the giver takes the yarn to the middle of the shed and the taker draws it out to the far side, either gripping its tip (the Dewas method) or as a loop that straightens (the Gabler method). Rigid rods need floor space of at least twice the cloth width beside the loom, which flexible tapes, wound on wheels, avoid (ITU rapier notes). Because a solid carrier holds the yarn the whole way, the rapier takes the widest range of weft: Nm 254 to Nm 3 in spun yarn and up to 12 colours on one machine (Picanol Ultimax), 7 denier to 4,500 tex and up to 16 colours on another (Dornier P2). So fancy yarns, furnishing and most jacquard fashion cloth go on rapiers, though the figure itself comes from the shedding device, as the site’s guide to jacquard weaving explains.

A row of green rapier weaving machines weaving white cloth in a mill, weft cones mounted on a stand above the first machine
Rapier looms in a weaving shed. Photo source: Pinterest; the photographer is not recorded.

Air-jet looms

A main nozzle blows the measured weft into the shed; because a jet in open air soon slows, relay nozzles about every 50 mm fire in sequence to keep it moving, and a profiled reed with a tunnel in its wires guides the air (ITU jet weaving notes). Air drags best on a hairy yarn, so air-jets were built for spun weft and later adapted to filament: Picanol states Ne 100 to Ne 2.4 in spun yarn and 20 to 1,000 denier in filament (OmniPlus-i Connect). They are the fastest looms for staple-fibre cloth, and Toyota calls the air-jet “the most popular type of loom” (Toyota Industries). The price is compressed air; the site’s air-jet air consumption calculator turns nozzle air per pick into cubic metres an hour. How the nozzles are timed, and what the air costs, is set out in the site’s guide to the air-jet loom.

An air-jet weaving machine on a trade-show stand weaving wide indigo denim, the cloth rolled on the front beam
An air-jet loom weaving indigo denim at full width, with cut, bound edges rather than a shuttle selvedge. Photo source: a Made-in-China product listing.

Water-jet looms

A pump shoots a thin jet of water that drags the weft across. Water grips far better than air, so no relay nozzles are needed, but the yarn must not absorb it: “Since water is used only filament yarns (synthetic fabrics) can be woven” (Toyota Industries). Tsudakoma states a range from 8 dtex polyamide to 5,600 dtex polyester, with airbag and filter fabrics among its uses (Tsudakoma). The cloth leaves the loom wet and must be dried, and the water goes to drain or treatment (ITU notes). Widths are narrower: 150 to 230 cm, with 250 and 280 cm as options, on Tsudakoma’s current model (ZW8200 catalogue). The site’s water-jet insertion calculator works from pump pressure to jet velocity, and its guide to the water-jet loom covers water treatment and maintenance.

How fast is a shuttle loom compared with a shuttleless loom?

Two numbers describe loom speed. Picks per minute says how often the loom inserts a pick; weft insertion rate (WIR), in m/min, is ppm × the width the weft crosses, and says how much weft it lays. A narrow loom can show a high ppm and a low WIR. A speed quoted without saying which, and at what width, cannot be compared with anything. Picanol puts the change in its own history: its first (shuttle) machine “achieved a speed of approximately 140 wefts per minute”, its Ultimax rapier reaches “industrial speeds of more than 800 wefts per minute”, and its air-jet “up to 1,350 wefts per minute in weaving mills” (Picanol, 2 October 2023). The makers’ current figures, each an upper figure for a width and cloth of the maker’s choosing:

LoomSpeed, as the maker states itWidths offeredSource
Projectile: Itema P7300HP V8No ppm published; WIR up to 1,570 m/min220 to 655 cmItema brochure
Rapier: Lindauer Dornier P2Up to 600 ppm150 to 540 cmDornier
Rapier: Picanol UltimaxMore than 800 ppm in mills190 to 400 cmPicanol, 2 Oct 2023 (speed); brochure (width)
Air-jet: Picanol OmniPlus-i ConnectUp to 1,350 ppm in mills190 to 400 cmPicanol, 2 Oct 2023 (speed); brochure (width)
Air-jet: Tsudakoma ZAX001neo PlusMaximum working speed 1,350 rpm, on a 190 cm, two-colour, positive-cam machine150 to 390 cmTsudakoma; catalogue
Water-jet: Tsudakoma ZW8200“Exceeding 1,000 rpm”150 to 230 cm; 250 and 280 cm as optionsTsudakoma; catalogue

WIR shows why the projectile, slowest of the shuttleless looms in ppm, was built at all. A 1992 comparison of individual machines in Istanbul Technical University’s weaving course lists width, speed and WIR side by side (ITU, Weaving Technology II); one row per system:

Machine, 1992 comparisonWidth (m)Speed (rpm)WIR (m/min)
Jürgens shuttle loom (paper-machine clothing)11.648557
Sulzer Rüti projectile P72003.63331,200
Sulzer Rüti rapier G62001.9522992
Tsudakoma air-jet ZAX1.91,3422,550
Tsudakoma water-jet ZW1.71,5302,601

The projectile ran at under two-thirds of the rapier’s speed and laid 21% more weft, because it was nearly twice as wide. The one shuttle loom in the list, an 11.6 m Jürgens for paper-machine clothing running at 48 rpm, laid less than a quarter of the air-jet’s weft.

Worked example: one cloth on a shuttle loom, a rapier and an air-jet

Take the example fabric of the site’s weaving calculations page: a 63-inch cotton cloth at 80 picks per inch, on a reed width of 1.664 m. Weave it for an 8-hour shift at speeds the makers state: a shuttle loom at 140 ppm (Picanol’s first machine), a rapier at 600 (the Dornier P2’s maximum) and an air-jet at 1,350 (Picanol’s and Tsudakoma’s figure). Efficiency, the share of the shift the loom actually weaves, is 90% for the shuttleless looms, close to the 87.6% and 91.9% in a cost comparison in the ITU notes, and 80% for the shuttle loom, ten points lower: the bottom of the 10 to 15% efficiency advantage that UPTTI’s notes give shuttleless looms for time lost to pirn changes, mending and warp changes. The site’s loom production calculator does the rest: picks per hour = ppm × 60 × efficiency, and metres = picks ÷ PPI × 0.0254.

Same cloth, 8-hour shiftShuttle loomRapierAir-jet
Speed (ppm)1406001,350
Efficiency80%90%90%
Picks inserted per hour6,72032,40072,900
Cloth per hour2.13 m10.29 m23.15 m
Cloth per shift17.07 m82.30 m185.17 m
Cloth per day of three shifts51.2 m246.9 m555.5 m
Square metres per hour3.4116.4637.04
WIR at 1.664 m (ppm × width)233 m/min998 m/min2,246 m/min
Calculator, set to these figuresshuttle loomrapierair-jet

One air-jet makes as much of this cloth as nearly eleven shuttle looms (185.17 ÷ 17.07 = 10.8), and one rapier as nearly five. Most of the gap is speed: at the same 90% efficiency the shuttle loom still makes only 19.20 m a shift (calculator). These are ceilings built on the makers’ top speeds; a mill would run below them, and a later shuttle loom would beat 140 ppm. The shape of the answer does not change, which is why mills that compete on price per metre run air-jets or rapiers.

Selvedge: the closed edge of a shuttle loom, and the edges of a shuttleless one

On a shuttle loom the weft turns round the outermost warp end and comes back on the next pick, so each edge is closed by the weft itself and nothing is cut off: the true, or self, selvedge. Levi Strauss & Co. describes selvedge denim as “traditionally woven on narrow-width shuttle looms, producing a clean edge with no fringe” (Levi Strauss & Co.). A shuttleless loom cuts every pick, so its edges start as a fringe that must be locked another way. The site’s page on selvedges in woven fabrics shows the structures; the three a shuttleless loom uses are:

  • Tucked-in. A needle or an air jet folds each cut end back into the next shed. Rapier and air-jet makers offer mechanical and air tuck-in devices (Picanol), and on the projectile loom every selvedge can be tucked, 18 mm wide or up to 35 mm for special uses (Itema).
  • Leno. Two extra threads twist round each other between picks and grip the weft ends; the fringe outside is trimmed. It is the standard edge on air-jet and water-jet looms: Toyota’s air-jet ships with a “Left/right rotary full-leno selvage device” and offers tuck-in as an option (JAT910 catalogue), and Tsudakoma’s water-jet uses a planetary leno motion (ZW8200 catalogue).
  • Fused (melted). On thermoplastic yarns a heated element seals the cut ends. Itema offers a melting device on its rapier and melted selvedges on its projectile machine (Itema R9500EVO).

The trimmed fringe is waste. Many looms hold the weft at the far side with a few catch threads and cut the strip away (Toyota’s catalogue lists a “Waste selvage on the right with catch cord”), and a 2025 paper cites selvedge waste of 4 to 8% of the yarn used on shuttleless looms (Indian Journal of Fibre & Textile Research). Makers now sell devices to remove one strip, such as Itema’s iSAVER and Picanol’s EcoFill. A shuttle loom has no such waste.

Noise, power and cost

Noise. Toyota sums up the shuttle loom as “Vibration and noise are severe problems and high speed operation is difficult”, but calls gripper and rapier looms “noisy” too (Toyota Industries). Measured levels are of the same order whatever the loom: an average of 100 dB(A) in a weaving mill with shuttle looms (Medycyna Pracy, 1982), weaving looms in general “in the order of 100 dB(A)” (DGUV IFA, Germany), and 88.5% of weaving-section workers at an Indian powerloom unit exposed to 95 dB(A) or more in 2023 (Indian Journal of Otolaryngology, 2024). At these levels hearing protection is needed in any weaving shed.

Power. Weft insertion takes “one third to one half of the total energy requirement of the weaving machine”, and a textbook comparison in the ITU notes ranks the systems per square metre of cloth (ITU, Weaving Technology II):

Weft insertion systemkWh per m² of clothAgainst the projectile
Projectile0.2611.00
Shuttle (conventional)0.3601.38
Rapier (conventional)0.5171.98
Air-jet0.6522.50

The machines are older and undated, so read the order, not the numbers. The IIT Delhi course gives the same order per kilogram of cloth and adds the water-jet: air-jet 3.2, rapier 2.5, gripper 1.3 and water-jet 0.9 kWh/kg, with most of the air-jet’s share going to its compressor and the gripper using less power “than that of a shuttle loom” (NPTEL). Makers are closing the air-jet’s gap: Toyota states its current model uses 20% less air and 10% less power than the one before, under its own test conditions (Toyota, 2022), and Picanol that lowering compressor pressure by 1 bar saves about 7% of energy (Picanol, 2025). A water-jet adds cloth drying, which the ITU notes put at 2 to 3 kW, and waste-water treatment.

Cost. No maker publishes list prices. Every weaving machine costs more as it gets wider, so mills compare cost per metre per minute of weft insertion, not cost per loom (ITU notes). Whatever a shuttle loom costs, the worked example needs eleven of them, with their floor space and weavers, to match one air-jet, plus the pirn winding that a shuttleless shed does without.

Where shuttle looms survive: handloom, khadi, powerlooms and selvedge denim

Handloom and khadi. Hand weaving never gave up the shuttle, and in India the handloom is protected by law: an order under the Handlooms (Reservation of Articles for Production) Act, 1985 reserves 11 articles, from the saree to the chaddar, mekhala and phanek, “for exclusive production by handlooms” (Gazette order S.O. 2160(E), 3 September 2008). Khadi is defined by its hand processes: “any cloth woven on handlooms in India from cotton, silk or woollen yarn handspun in India or from a mixture of any two or all of such yarns” (KVIC Act, section 2(d)); the site’s guide to khadi covers the rest.

Rows of wooden handlooms in a dim workshop, a weaver seated at one of them on the left
Wooden handlooms in a workshop. On a handloom the shuttle is still the weft carrier.

Powerlooms. India’s decentralised powerloom sector still runs plain shuttle looms, and the Ministry of Textiles has spent years upgrading them: its PowerTex India scheme subsidised a plain loom to a semi-automatic shuttle loom, a semi-automatic shuttle loom to a rapier, or a plain loom straight to a rapier (PIB, 13 December 2019), and “more than 2.16 lakh looms” had been upgraded by August 2018 (PIB, 1 August 2018).

Selvedge denim. Here the shuttle survives for its edge, and the edge comes with a narrow width. Cone Mills wove Levi’s 501 denim “on 29-inch wide looms” from 1927, and “around 1984, Cone Mills adopted a more modern, economical wide loom, doubling the width of its denim that could be cut in the middle and eliminating the need for selvedge” (Levi Strauss & Co., 2023). Cone’s White Oak plant in North Carolina kept American Draper X3 shuttle looms, some dating “as far back as the 1940s”, until it closed at the end of 2017 (Textile World, 2019). Uniqlo, which buys selvedge denim from Japan’s Kaihara, says it “can only be woven at a width of 31″, about half the width of non-selvedge denim” (Uniqlo), on Toyota’s G9 shuttle loom, at “one-sixth of that of computerized looms”: 131 yards, about 120 m, in 24 hours (Uniqlo). The site’s page on denim weaving covers the rest of the process.

View along a wooden loom with a striped warp in yellow, red, blue and green, woven into a checked cloth at the front
A striped warp on a wooden loom, woven into a check.

Questions

What is a shuttle loom machine?

A loom that inserts the weft with a shuttle, a carrier holding a pirn of yarn, struck from one side of the warp to the other and back. Because the same unbroken thread turns at each edge, it weaves a closed selvedge with no waste. By modern standards it is slow and loud: Picanol’s first shuttle machine ran at about 140 picks a minute.

What are shuttleless looms, and what types are there?

Looms that keep the weft on a cone beside the machine and send only a measured length across, cutting it at each edge. The four main types are named after what carries the weft: projectile (a small gripper), rapier (a rod or tape), air-jet and water-jet. They run faster and wider than shuttle looms and never stop to change a pirn.

How fast is a shuttle loom compared with a rapier or air-jet loom?

Picanol’s first shuttle loom ran at about 140 picks per minute; its current rapier reaches more than 800 in mills and its air-jet up to 1,350. On the same 63-inch cloth at 80 picks per inch, that is 17.07 m a shift for the shuttle loom at 80% efficiency, 82.30 m for a rapier at 600 picks and 185.17 m for an air-jet at 1,350, both at 90%.

What is a leno selvedge?

An edge made on shuttleless looms by two extra threads that twist round each other between the picks and lock the cut weft ends; the fringe outside them is then trimmed. It is the standard selvedge on air-jet and water-jet looms. The alternatives are a tucked-in selvedge, with each cut end folded back into the next shed, and a fused selvedge for thermoplastic yarns.

How much does a water-jet loom produce per day?

Metres per day = rpm × 60 × 24 × efficiency ÷ (picks per inch × 39.37). A water-jet at 1,000 rpm, the speed Tsudakoma says its current model exceeds, at 90% efficiency on a filament cloth of 100 picks per inch, makes 329.18 m in 24 hours (calculator, set to these figures). Halve the pick density and the output doubles.

Why is selvedge denim woven on shuttle looms?

Because the closed edge is the point, and a shuttleless loom, which cuts every pick, cannot make it. Levi Strauss & Co. describes selvedge denim as “traditionally woven on narrow-width shuttle looms, producing a clean edge with no fringe”. Uniqlo gives the width of Kaihara’s selvedge denim as 31 inches, about half that of ordinary denim, and says its G9 shuttle looms make one-sixth as much as modern looms.

Sources

How this page is kept

Last verified: 11 October 2026. Machine speeds, widths and yarn ranges are the makers’ own figures, read on their sites or brochures on that date and attributed to the model they describe; when a maker launches a new model the figure is replaced, not averaged. Textbook figures, such as the 1992 machine comparison and the energy rankings, come from university course material and are labelled with their age. The worked example uses the site’s loom production calculator as it stood on this date, and every prefilled link was opened to check it shows the figures quoted.

Change log. 11 October 2026: rewritten in full. The earlier version gave no speed, width or source, and is corrected on these points: it left the rapier out of the shuttleless looms; it called the water-jet a gentle method for delicate fabrics, when it weaves only synthetic filament; it said shuttleless looms use less energy, when the air-jet uses the most of any system; it credited the shuttle and projectile looms with finer pattern control, which comes from the shedding device; it said shuttleless looms are quieter, when looms in general run at about 100 dB(A); and its three unnamed mill “case studies”, including a 50% speed gain, could not be traced and are withdrawn.

Found an error, or a newer figure from a maker? Please tell us through the contact page, naming the section and the source that disagrees.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top

Follow on WhatsApp

Scan with your phone’s camera to open the channel, then tap Follow.

QR code for the WhatsApp channelOr open WhatsApp on this device

The Selvedge · free · one email a week

Know what changed in textiles this week.

Our register tracks 3,130 textile standards. Nobody reads them all, so once a week we tell you which ones moved, and what else is new.

  • Standards added, revised or withdrawn that week
  • One textile calculation, worked through to its answer
  • New and revised guides on the site
  • Textile fairs coming up, with their dates

Free when you confirm: Spinning and Weaving Calculations (PDF). 49 calculations, from the blowroom to the loom, each with its formulas and a worked example.

We send a confirmation link first. Unsubscribe in one click, any time.

  • No spam
  • Your address is not shared
  • Unsubscribe in one click